Cincinnati Collectibles & Vintage Treasures

Timed auction by New Seasons Auction & Estates

Starts Sep 23, 2026 7:35 PM EDT. Ends Sep 30, 2026 6:30 PM EDT

Preview is Thursday, September 24, 11:00 am-7:00 pm and Friday, September 25, 9:00 am-4:00 pm. Pick up will be Thursday, October 1 11:00 am-7:00 pm and Friday, October 2, 9:00 am-4:00 pm @ 201 Third St., Aurora, IN.  Please Note: A 7% sales tax, 3% credit card processing fee, and 12% buyer’s premium will be added to all winning bids. Step into a packed auction featuring an incredible variety of vintage treasures, collectible sports cards, furniture, tools, records, glassware, pottery, coins, jewelry, toys, and more. From Tom Brady and Joe Burrow professionally graded football cards to Cincinnati Reds collectibles, Tiffany & Co., Waterford, Roseville Pottery, vintage vinyl, silver coins, and quality tools, this sale offers something for collectors, decorators, sports fans, and treasure hunters alike. With hundreds of lots spanning generations and collecting interests, there are plenty of opportunities to discover something special. Featured Highlights Tom Brady and Joe Burrow Professionally Graded Football Cards Mint 10 Fernando Mendoza Rookie Cards Cincinnati Bengals and Cincinnati Reds Sports Cards Signed Baseball Cards Featuring Barry Larkin, Lou Piniella, and More Joey Votto Rookie and Certified Autograph Cards Big Red Machine 1970s Team Plaque and Johnny Bench Poster 1975/1976 Cincinnati Reds Hall of Fame Silver-Plated Medallion Set Tiffany & Co. "Millennium" Crystal Bowl with Original Box Waterford Crystal Tumblers and Crystal Bowl Lenox Lead Crystal and Lenox "Love" Bowl Roseville, Van Briggle, Hull, McCoy, Goebel and F. Crosby Pottery Vintage Fenton Glass, Westmoreland Milk Glass and Indiana Glass Mikasa Crystal, Gorham and Towle Sterling 14K Yellow Gold Amethyst Earrings and Sterling Jewelry 1921 Morgan Dollars and 1922/1923 Peace Dollars Buffalo Nickels and Assorted U.S. Quarters Vintage Vinyl Featuring The Beatles, Frank Sinatra, Ray Charles, Tina Turner, Eric Clapton, Tom Petty, Luke Combs and More Craftsman, Eagle Tools, DeWalt, Porter Cable, Stanley and Sears Tools Sligh Chippendale Writing Desks and Hand-Carved Oriental Furniture High-End Italian Calligaris "Jam" Chair Set Vintage Fisher Price Playsets, Pokémon, Marvel, DC and Other Toys Auction Categories Sports Cards & Memorabilia Cincinnati Reds Collectibles Cincinnati Bengals Collectibles Football & Baseball Cards Coins & Currency Gold & Sterling Jewelry Vintage & Costume Jewelry Fine Crystal & Glassware Fenton & Milk Glass Roseville & Vintage Pottery Furniture & Home Furnishings Mid-Century Modern Decor Vintage Vinyl Records Vintage Radios & Electronics Tools & Workshop Equipment Lawn & Garden Equipment Antique & Primitive Decor Vintage Toys & Fisher Price Comics & Pop Culture Christmas & Holiday Decor

Lots

Showing the first 100 of 239 lots.